The Anthropocene fallacy
Earthset
In April 2026, the four astronauts of Artemis II swung around the far side of the Moon, the first people to travel there in more than half a century. On April 6, through Orion’s window, they photographed Earth as a thin crescent sinking behind the cratered lunar horizon. NASA called it Earthset. Apollo 8 gave an earlier generation Earthrise. This was ours, and when I saw it, something shifted. That small, fragile crescent is everything we have.
Astronauts have described that jolt for decades. The writer Frank White later gave it a name: the Overview Effect. From orbit, the atmosphere is a thin blue line hugging a rock. You can see storms, coastlines, the glow of cities at night. What you can’t see is a single border.
Everyone you have ever loved is down there. So is every ancestor, every war, every empire that rose and fell. All of it fits in one frame, on one small planet, with nowhere else to go.
Back on the ground, it’s remarkably easy to forget that.
Mars won’t save us
So naturally, our big plan for the future is to leave. Mars gets pitched as humanity’s insurance policy, a second home in case we wreck the first. It makes a thrilling keynote. It also raises a lot of money and turns a handful of very wealthy men into folk heroes.
Look at the actual planet, though. Mars has no breathable air, no magnetic field to shield you from radiation, and soil laced with toxic perchlorates. Its average temperature is around minus 60°C. Earth after a nuclear war, a supervolcano or the worst climate scenario we can model would still be kinder to human life than Mars on its best day.
The real danger of the backup plan isn’t that it might fail. It’s what it does to how we treat the original. If there’s a spare planet waiting, this one starts to feel disposable.
And the irony is hard to miss. We’ll talk seriously about spending trillions to manufacture air on a dead world, while the air, water and soil we were handed for free get polluted, privatised and sold back to us.
The hallucination of value
Zoom out far enough and something strange happens. The things we treat as the most important parts of our lives start to dissolve: the salary, the mortgage, the share price, which side of a line on a map we happened to be born on. They don’t disappear because they’re hidden. They disappear because, at that scale, they were only ever ideas we all agreed to hold in our heads at the same time. A collective hallucination, and we have built our entire lives around it.
Money, borders and ownership are agreements: stories we tell each other so millions of strangers can cooperate. Useful stories, genuinely. But a banknote is paper. A bank balance is a number on a server. A border is a line somebody drew on a map, often not that long ago. They hold exactly as much power as we collectively give them. If everyone stopped believing in the dollar tomorrow, it would be worthless by lunchtime, and the sun would still come up.
Here’s what gets me. Every other species gets food, water and shelter simply by being part of the world. A bird doesn’t invoice the tree. A deer doesn’t take out a loan to drink from the river. We’re the only species that has to earn the right to stay alive, and we have to earn it in a currency we made up.
The stories aren’t the problem. Forgetting they’re stories is. Somewhere along the way we started treating the market like gravity and GDP like a law of physics. So we cut down real forests, drain real aquifers and fight real wars to protect numbers in a ledger. From the ground, that looks like the economy. From orbit, it looks like a species lost in its own dream.
Deep time doesn’t care
Zoom out further, from space to time, and things get stranger. And oddly calmer.
We talk about saving the planet, but the planet will be fine. Earth has been hit by asteroids, frozen almost pole to pole, and lived through five mass extinctions. Each time, life came back in new shapes. What’s actually at stake is whether we’re still one of them.
Give it a few million years and our cities won’t be grand ruins. They’ll be a thin, odd stripe in the rock: concrete dust, plastic, aluminium, a trace of isotopes from nuclear tests. Geologists already have a word for what will be left in it: technofossils. Our entire civilisation, a few centimetres thick.
And the planet keeps working. Rivers grind what we built into sediment. Plate tectonics slowly drags the ocean floor, and everything that settled on it, down into the mantle, where it melts and eventually rises again as new rock. The Earth recycles our mistakes into a world that won’t remember us.
I find that humbling, and strangely freeing. The question was never whether Earth survives. It’s whether we get to stay.
Wake up
Picture a crew aboard a perfectly good ship. The hull is sound, the engines run, the galley restocks itself. And the crew spends its days arguing over who gets to sell lifeboat tickets, prying planks off the deck to pay for them.
That’s roughly where we are. We’re racing for a kind of wealth that only exists because we agreed it does, while ignoring the kind right in front of us: clean air, sunlight, fertile soil, each other.
Take the view from orbit seriously and the system we’ve built starts to look less like a law of nature and more like a glitch. The planet is a self-regulating, self-repairing marvel. We’re the only part of it that’s forgotten how to simply belong here.
Maybe it’s time we stopped staring at the market and looked back at the Marble.